Imprint Digital
REPLAY3CE vs Old Agency · FINAL+1,038% · SEASONDec '24 · May '25 · PLAY OF GAMEP-Max Rebuild · AD CONV+776% · LEAD FORMS+1,033% · CPL−39.8% ·
The Replay Case File · Three Crowns Electric

+1,038% organic.
+776% ad conversions.

BEFORE · Old Agency
VS
Imprint · AFTER
Org Traffic
+1,038%
▲ YoY
Ad Conv.
+776%
▲ Q2
Lead Forms
+1,033%
▲ Q2
Cost / Conv.
−39.8%
▼ Q2
Season · Dec 2024 · May 2025 ▮ Final Score Verified · GA4 + Google Ads
Three Crowns Electric case study hero
CASE FILE · 2025 Three Crowns Electric · Electrical Services

Where they were when they called.

Three Crowns Electric came to us after under-performing agency work. Minimal SEO movement. A Google Ads account flipping on and off without a plan. Lead volume flat, cost-per-lead climbing. The kind of file that arrives at our door once a month · and the kind we know we can fix in a season.

The prior agency had been running Google Ads campaigns for two years with no documented strategy. Conversion actions were stale. The site's money pages were generic templates, and the technical SEO foundation had broken redirects, slow Core Web Vitals, and indexation gaps that Google's algorithm read as "not authoritative."

Organic traffic had been flat for 18 months. Every dollar going into ads was being measured against a conversion event that no longer triggered for the actions that mattered · booked service calls. So the dashboard said "winning," and the field said "still empty."

"Hire the wrong agency once. Hire us next. That's the actual cost of an underperforming partner · the year you don't get back."

The brief we wrote in week one: fix the tracking, rebuild the foundation, restart the channels in the right order. Not a band-aid. Not a vibe shift. A full-funnel rebuild · three months of foundation, three months of compounding lift.

Four plays. In order.

Channels don't compound when they're run in parallel from day one · they compound when they're staged in the right order. Foundation first. Demand capture second. Demand creation third. Each play stacks on the one before it.

01
First DownFoundation

Fix the tracking. Verify every conversion action.

Audited GA4 events, rebuilt conversion actions to fire on actual service-call bookings, deduplicated phone-call events from missed-call replays. Tracking layer became honest before any spend layered on top.

Result
+1,033%
Lead forms
02
Second DownTechnical SEO

Rebuild the foundation under the search ranking.

Crawl audit + redirect cleanup. CWV optimization. Schema markup on service pages. Internal link architecture rebuilt around money-page hubs. The Google algorithm rewards trust signals · we rebuilt them all at once.

Result
+1,038%
Org Traffic YoY
03
Third DownPaid Search

Restart Google Ads with intent-matched campaigns.

Killed the broad-match keyword sprawl. Restructured into intent-matched ad groups · "panel upgrade" gets a different ad than "outlet repair." Negative keyword list weekly. Quality Score rose, cost dropped, conversion rate doubled.

Result
+776%
Ad conversions
04
TouchdownPerformance Max

Performance Max layered on top · for compounding scale.

With the foundation honest and the search ads converting, layered a Performance Max campaign for demand creation. Asset groups built around each money page. CPL fell as the algorithm learned the audience.

Result
−39.8%
Cost per conv.

The plays that broke open the game.

Three moments where the channel went from "moving" to "compounding." Watch the bars.

PLAY OF GAME
+1,038%
Organic Traffic YoY

Eight months of technical + content compounding. The flat line broke into a clean upward curve at month 4 and accelerated through month 8.

SECOND HALF
+776%
Ad Conversions

Intent-matched ad groups + P-Max layered on top. The algorithm learned, the conversion rate doubled, and cost-per-conversion fell hard.

CLOSER
−39.8%
Cost per Conversion

Quality Score climbed, the algorithm got smarter, the wasted impressions dropped. Same budget · vastly more booked service calls.

The interview.

After two years with the prior agency, our dashboard looked busy and our calendar looked empty. Imprint rebuilt the whole thing from the tracking up. Eight months later, we're booked out, the cost per lead is cut in half, and the team finally trusts the numbers.

· Operations Director
Three Crowns Electric · NoCo

Your season starts
with one call.

Tell us what's broken, what's flat, and where you want the number to be in 90 days. We'll come back with a real playbook, named owners, and the receipt we'll put in writing.

Book the First Call
★★★★★
5.0 / 70+ reviews Google verified
Ready to put your mark on it? 90-day plan · named owners
Get Your Free Consultation